Gymnastics Fail: Fierce Five Off the Podium at the American Cup by Dvora Meyers

by | Mar 10, 2013 | Articles

Screen Shot 2013-03-09 at 9.42.56 PM

Gabby Douglas and Aly Raisman, hanging out on the sidelines at the American Cup.

What a difference a year makes. Last year, the American Cup was held at Madison Square Garden to a near capacity crowd with former champions—Mary Lou Retton, Carly Patterson and inaugural winner, Nadia Comaneci—in attendance. Bela Karolyi had emerged from his between-the-Olympics hibernation to mutter indecipherably for the cameras. Gabby Douglas, in a sign of things to come, unofficially won the all-around competition, beating the favorite and defending world champion, Jordyn Wieber.

Fast forward one year to the 2013 American Cup held this time in Worcester to much less fanfare. The “Fierce Five” were arguably the biggest story coming out of the London Olympics yet none of the stars competed. Can you imagine Tom Brady winning the Super Bowl and not playing on opening weekend the next season? We might’ve seen the frontrunners for Rio, but the Olympic team’s absence from this year’s American Cup illustrates why gymnastics will only be popular in Olympic years, even as it tries for greater multi-year popularity.

As a longtime fan of the sport, it pains me to admit this. When I was a kid, I’d search the TV Guide for gymnastics listings, which, if they ever appeared, came right after “golf.” According to my recollection, golf always seemed to be on. I couldn’t understand why the networks preferred to broadcast a bunch of white guys putting over girls in leotards flipping. (I probably never will.)

But as I watched the competition, I understood why other sports not oriented towards one specific competition that takes places once every four years have more of a shot at year-round popularity.

First, there is the lack of continuity. After the Games, many athletes retire or take time off. Though Gabby Douglas and Aly Raisman were present for press and fans, they did not compete. Douglas announced that she is set to return to training in Iowa in May; Raisman would not put a date on her return to competitive form. Certainly it won’t happen before her run on DWTS ends. Kyla Ross had originally been slated to compete, but withdrew with a bruised heel (she performed an exhibition routine after the meet concluded).

Screen Shot 2013-03-09 at 9.56.32 PM

Olympic gold medalist, Kyla Ross, performs an exhibition beam routine, after the meet.

What does this mean for any of the new fans that the sport accrued during a very successful Olympics? It means they have less incentive to tune in if their favorites aren’t competing. Imagine the type of press the meet would’ve received had Douglas or Raisman competed. (Maroney, perhaps the most popular Olympic team member, is still recovering from two leg surgeries.)

Also, every four years the rulebook of gymnastics changes. Spectators who might’ve come to understand the scoring by the time the competition in London ended will have to learn a new set of requirements if they wish to follow the meets in the next quadrennium. That’s a big investment of time and energy. Only the hardcores are willing to go that extra mile.

Screen Shot 2013-03-09 at 9.53.26 PM

American Cup champion, Katelyn Ohashi.

Other popular sports thrive on sameness. I watch exactly one football game a year—the Super Bowl—and yet I know what’s going on each time I tune in. A touchdown, a field goal, a first down—they’re all as I remember them from the previous year (and worth the same number of points). The game appears unchanged to the untrained eye. And for other popular team sports, all you really need is an untrained eye to follow what’s going on.

And though every year brings some new rookies, enough of the older players remain so fans aren’t expected to learn a completely new roster each year. There is continuity—both with the rules and stars—from year to year.

This lack of continuity isn’t the fault of USA Gymnastics or any of the individual athletes. After years of intense training, it is understandable that the gymnasts would want to take time off and enjoy all of the opportunities that come their way. The window for gymnasts making money off the sport is very limited so they must take advantage of it immediately. They might also need this downtime in order to let their bodies recover from the brutal Olympic preparation process. Nearly every gymnast is competing with some form of hurt.

The gymnasts can take a break, comforted by the knowledge that this year doesn’t actually matter, in the Olympic scheme of things. And therein lies an additional problem—the fact that one year in four has drastically lower stakes than the rest. Without stakes and drama, you lose excitement and quite possibly, the audience too.

Screen Shot 2013-03-09 at 9.50.45 PM

Superhuman, American Cup runner-up, Bannon’s Simone Biles.

Even the athletes acknowledged the lowered stakes in their post-meet interviews. All seemed particularly focused on testing out new skills and routines for the coming years. Competing them perfectly, while desirable, wasn’t their top priority. In gymnastics, 2013 is sort of like a year-long preseason.

Will Ohashi and Biles be in Rio in 2016? While I would love to see both girls (and especially Ohashi’s dimples) in Brazil, looking towards the Olympics in the year after the previous Games is like trying to pick an Oscar contender in March. (In that case, I would’ve gone with 21 Jump Street.) It’s not exactly the right time to be placing bets.

The greater question is how can a sport that is arguably the most popular during the Games transcend the Olympics and become popular in its own right? Or is gymnastics virtually nothing without the Olympic Games at the end of the four-year tunnel?

Dvora Meyers is a freelance writer who’s work has appeared in The Atlantic, Slate and Deadspin. Follow her at Unorthodox Gymnastics.

Subscribe
Notify of
guest
3 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Amy
Amy
8 years ago

Great article! Sadly, I don’t think it’s ever going to change. Leaders like Martha Karolyi like having fresh meat and don’t care that there’s a lack of continuity. I respect what she’s done with the team, but, I think USA Gymnastics needs to do a better job of raising the profile of gymnastics all year, every year. That means getting US athletes in more international meets and doing a better job of negotiating with the networks.

KatieJAcks
KatieJAcks
8 years ago
Reply to  Amy

Well said, Amy. I think USA Gymnastics needs to do a better job at covering these events. In addition, gymnastics fails to have the following it does because of the perceived notion that these gymnasts are starving, deprived, and oppressed young girls. The image of elite gymnastics portrayed in the media during the 80s and 90s is still prevalent today. Most of my friends don’t understand my love of the sport because of their perception of the sport due to what they watched on NBC growing up. As intriguing as fluff pieces were, they did a significant amount of damage to the long term perception of the sport.

Ashley DBD
Ashley DBD
5 years ago

So many great points. I think for a lot of these reasons is why, when it comes to being a gymnastics fan, NCAA is the way to go. Don’t get me wrong, as a college gymnast myself, I am a lifelong fan of all aspects of the sport and during the London Games got very little sleep so I could stay up watching the delayed broadcast of the gymnastics after desperately avoiding all forms of media during the day. But when it comes down to it, yes the post Olympic year is not that exciting. There is a lot of turn over and you never really know who is going to be at the top in the next four years. So when it comes to following the sport, I am all about the NCAA. I follow UCLA gymnastics like most people follow their favorite football teams. I want to know who is being recruited, who is injured, who is in the line-up. I want to know everything about the Bruins. And I also keep track of other teams because, just like football, you have to know how the other teams are doing, so you know how your team stacks up. You also solve a lot of the problems you discuss here. You have continuity of the athletes year to year, the rules mostly stay the same, for the women you still have the 10.0 to keep the casual fan somewhat informed, and you can actually make decent predictions about who is going to be competing in Super 6.

To summarize, while I wish everyone followed the American Cup, most people follow gymnastics in a four year cycle to varying degrees. But what can you follow every year with consistency of the the athletes and rules, the NCAA.

Who knows, maybe getting people to watch NCAA will get them more involved in the elite events as well. For the women, its how you look at potential recruits, and for the men, how to see what your favorite college athletes are up to today. And if you are really lucky, you might even see some of your favorite female athletes return to elite (i.e. Mohini and Anna).

While my friends count down the Sundays until the next football season starts, I impatiently wait for January and more Bruin gymnastics. At least I have the elite competitions and this podcast to tide me over.

Related